Roll up, roll up. The lights come up on the neighbour from the fifth floor, applauding a mayor. It was June 2024, and Barcelona’s mayor, Jaume Collboni, had just announced, very pleased with himself, that tourist flats in the city would be gone by November 2028 and that those 10,000 homes would go back to local people. To the neighbour on the fifth floor it sounded like common sense: if there are not enough flats, stop letting them to tourists and give them back to the people who live here. So she clapped even harder.
It sounds good, I will give him that. It has everything a political line needs to succeed: it fits in a headline, it makes sense the first time you hear it, and nobody checks it.
I did.
First, a confession. I am 52 and I have seen governments of every colour. I have lived through politics at close quarters, and when you have watched it that closely for that long, you develop a thick skin. I no longer believe the films, because I know the plot, I know the characters and, saddest of all, I often know the ending.
And a second confession, so that nobody has to dig it up later: I run a company that manages short-term rentals. I have been doing this for sixteen years. I am not writing from the outside, and that is precisely why I know how to count.
I do not want to play down the crisis. It is real, and some people are having a very hard time. This autumn we saw it in Maricarmen, an 87-year-old woman evicted in Madrid from the flat she had lived in for seventy years. It was shameful on both sides: in how things got that far, and in how the story was used afterwards. Six days later, the lights come up on the Government approving the decree that people on the street called “the Maricarmen decree”. The audience applauds, and loudly. But inside, alongside the measures against evictions, were VAT at 10% on tourist flats and a property tax (IBI) surcharge that the preamble itself explains quite openly: local councils will be able to “penalise, through the Property Tax, the use of a home for anything other than residence”. Maricarmen did not live in a tourist flat, and it was not a tourist who evicted her. But her story was used to sell a package in which, as it happened, other people paid. End of scene.
From 10,000 to 3,000
Back to Barcelona and the mayor’s promise. The city has 10,627 tourist-flat licences, 1.3% of its homes. What nobody mentions is that not all of those licences are in use. A licence is a piece of paper, not a flat with tourists in it. Some people took one out years ago and live in the flat. Some use it for a couple of weeks in August. Some never used it at all, to avoid trouble with the neighbours. And so on. If we look at how many different licence numbers appear in Airbnb listings, we get about 5,000, and Spain’s statistics office, the INE, arrives at a similar figure: the flats actually let to tourists amount to around 0.6% of the city’s homes. Add the ones that are only on Booking and, being generous, call it 6,000.
Scene two begins. The lights pick out the mayor and someone asks him a question: what will each of those owners do on the day they lose their licence? The mayor, with his best smile and full make-up, replies that the flats will go to a local family, to a person with a disability, to a decent neighbour. And the neighbour on the fifth floor claps harder still. But in the next sequence we see those owners selling the flat, or simply shutting it up until the market is kinder to them. What they will not do is rent it out. Renting needs trust, and trust is exactly what was lost years ago. With new decrees every week, all of them against owners and each one adding legal uncertainty, renting out again is too risky. Nobody puts their home into something they may never be able to get it back from.
Back to the sums. I will be generous again: let us say half of them do put the flat on the long-term market. That leaves you, Mr Mayor, with just 3,000 flats. Less than 0.4% of Barcelona’s homes: four in every thousand. The mayor comes back on stage, a little sweatier this time and looking nervous. Lights. And you have to ask: is that the solution we are being sold for a city short of housing, handing back four homes in every thousand? It solves nothing. It does not move rents, it does not fix the housing problem, and you know it. The mayor leaves the stage as the light fades out.
Let us try an exercise. Have you ever wondered how many offices and business premises in Barcelona could become homes again? I mean flats that were once homes and are now offices, in buildings where people could perfectly well live. It was hard to arrive at a figure, but my estimate is around 30,000. Imagine that tomorrow we were told this is where the problem lies: that the lawyer and his office, the hairdresser and her salon, the accountant and his practice must be expropriated, and that this is the solution. It sounds odd, does it not? It is the same logic, with three times as many flats.
The lights go down again and we break for an interval.
Interval
As I said at the start, we have seen this film before. Catalonia capped rents in 2020, with a law the Constitutional Court struck down in 2022, and capped them again in March 2024, when the city was declared a stressed housing market. But look at what happened to the flats: owners took thousands off the market, contracts that were about to be signed were cancelled, and owners, understandably, took fright. Supply has fallen by roughly 15% since then, and it is still falling. The result: a flat comes up for rent and within a day 200 people are interested. And what does the letting agent do? Naturally, they choose the best candidate, the one with the strongest finances. In other words, those with the least are left out. The lights come up on the mayor again. Someone asks him: “But wasn’t all this meant to help those of us who need a rented home the most?” Close-up on the mayor. Fade to black.
Prices ease on paper while the flats disappear in real life. And a family looking for a home does not live in a price index. It lives in the flat it finds, or in the one it does not.
As if that were not enough, the plot takes a turn and a character we all know steps onto the stage: the con artist. Where supply is short, someone will take advantage. When so many people are chasing so few flats, adverts for flats that do not exist start to spring up: a price that looks like a gift, and urgency, a great deal of urgency. Lots of people are interested, they tell you; if you do not pay the deposit today, you will lose it. The person pays and the advertiser vanishes. This very November, the Guardia Civil broke up two groups in Madrid and Barcelona that were doing exactly this to students and to people looking for somewhere to stay. So there are not only fewer flats: there are also more traps for those who need one most. Even here, the person who suffers is the very one our friend the mayor says he wants to protect.
They say man is the only animal that trips over the same stone twice. With rented housing we have tripped several times now, and the stone keeps getting bigger.
What the picture leaves out
The lights come up and the director turns the spotlight on something rarely discussed: what is lost when tourist flats are abolished. And onto the stage steps the most dreadful character of all: the short-term rental manager, or simply the host with a legal flat on Airbnb.
When you abolish a tourist flat, you are not just removing a flat. You are removing the person who cleans it every morning, the laundry that washes its sheets, the technician who comes round on a Sunday because the boiler has broken down, whoever waits for the guests with the keys at eleven at night, and the bar on the corner where the guests have breakfast and lunch. According to a PwC report commissioned by Apartur, the Barcelona tourist-flat association, more than 40,000 jobs in the city depend directly or indirectly on tourist flats. Yes, you read that correctly: forty thousand people work behind these “speculators”, and many of them pay their own rent with those wages.
The same report estimates that in 2023 these flats generated around €1.9 billion for the city, 1.9% of its GDP, much of it in restaurants, shops and leisure. That money does not stay in the flat. It goes out into the street.
And then there is us. For sixteen years we have welcomed people from all over the world. We are the first to open the city’s door to them, the ones who greet them: we hand over the keys, tell them where to find the best bread in the neighbourhood, fix the air conditioning on a Saturday in August and ask them to keep their voices down on the stairs, because the neighbours are asleep. We do it with respect, with honesty and with enormous affection for this city. For years we have seen it for what it is: a way of being ambassadors for Barcelona, knowing that neighbours come first and guests second, because respect is what makes living together work.
But the scene does not end there. Now the spotlight turns to what a tourist flat gives back to the community, because, for the villains of the film, they pay rather a lot. A great deal, I would say. Here is the bill.
In 2012 the tourist tax was €0.65 per person per night. Today it is €9.50. Guests pay it, but the owner collects it and files it every six months, and any mistake brings fines. According to the industry, in 2023 the tourist tax on these flats raised about 60 million euros, at a rate that was almost half of today’s. Apartur also estimates around €160 million a year in direct taxes.
And that was before this autumn’s decrees. From 1 December 2026, VAT at 10% applies to every booking. Using public data from Airbnb listings, and keeping the sums conservative, that comes to between €17 million and €30 million a year, paid by guests and passed on to the tax authorities.
And there is more. The same city council that wants them gone gave initial approval in October to raising their property tax (IBI) by up to 150%: between €7 million and €8 million more a year, by its own estimate. The first surcharge falls due at the end of 2027. Ten months later, the licences expire. It is like putting up the rent for a tenant you have already told to leave.
And then something happens: the neighbour on the second floor wonders how many social homes could be built every year with all that money. Silence across the theatre.
It is also worth remembering that this is not a lawless sector. Barcelona stopped issuing licences in 2015: since then, not a single new legal tourist flat. And since every law has its loophole, illegal flats walk onto the stage. The city council went after them with fines of between 60,001 and 600,000 euros and, to be fair, it worked. People were frightened, and rightly so. Since 2016 it has issued more than 10,600 closure orders. Then came the agreement with Airbnb: no licence, no listing. Between 2017 and 2020 the council asked for more than 11,000 listings to be taken down. What is left today is a closed, closely watched sector, and one that pays.
Enter the man from the fifth floor, first door, who asks shyly: “But if getting rid of tourist flats also means getting rid of all that money for the state, and thousands of people lose their jobs… is it really a good idea?” The woman from the first floor, fourth door, looks unconvinced. She has a friend whose tourist flat is his retirement plan, because he is frightened of how little his pension will be.
Clapperboard. The scene ends and another begins.
Who wins
There is something else people forget. Airbnb began with two young men blowing up air mattresses in their living room in San Francisco and, without meaning to, they upended a business that had belonged to the hotels. For a moment, the tourism pie was in the hands of ordinary people. Remarkable.
It also changed the way many people travel. A family of four in a hotel pays for two rooms. In a flat they have a kitchen, a living room and, with what they save, the chance to travel again next year. If tourist flats disappear, that family will still travel, but less often, or for a lot more money.
The lights come up again and onto the stage steps a character everyone knows: the hotel chain. The scene moves to New York, which has already tried abolishing tourist flats. In 2023 it reduced short-term rentals to almost nothing. A year later, according to CoStar data published by Airbnb, hotel rooms were at the highest prices in their history: tourist flats were no longer getting in their way. And rents, which were the whole point? In May 2026 New York’s median rent had risen by almost 8% in a year, to $4,199 a month, the highest since StreetEasy began measuring it in 2010. And it is still rising. The camera finds a hotelier with a cigar in his mouth, laughing at a table with his lobbyists.
A right billed to the neighbour
But the film is not over yet; this is only the beginning. Questions and more questions, now in front of the television: when did the right to housing become something you claim from a private individual?
It is worth reading the Spanish Constitution, because it is very clear. Article 47 says: “All Spaniards have the right to enjoy decent and adequate housing. The public authorities shall promote the necessary conditions and establish appropriate standards in order to make this right effective.” The public authorities. Not the owner.
Health works the same way. We have the right to have our health protected (Article 43), and nobody would dream of demanding that the neighbour who happens to be a doctor see patients for free in his living room. That is what hospitals are for. With housing, though, politics has found a shortcut: instead of building, it points the finger. It is a curious logic: I have a right to what is yours, and you have to give it to me.
Enter the housing minister, who announces that social housing makes up about 3% of Spain’s housing stock. The European average is around 8%. That is the duty that has not been met, and it is not the owner’s.
I know what people will say: that property has a social function. That is true, and the Constitution says so too, in Article 33. But the law setting rules for my property is one thing. Politics turning my property into the excuse for everything it has failed to build (and I mean property in general, not just mine) is something else entirely.
And there is a detail I love. The same Article 47 ends by asking the public authorities to regulate land use “in order to prevent speculation”. The word is right there, in the Constitution. It says nothing, mind you, about speculating with promises.
And then my father walks onto the stage. He used to tell me: “Information is power, and the best antidote to being manipulated.” It always stayed with me, but it took me years to understand the small print: the antidote is no use in the bottle. You have to take it, and taking it is hard work, because it makes you think, dig deeper and pull off the masks. The lie, on the other hand, comes ready-made, enemy included and ready for applause.
And now, the final scene
Let us do the last sum. The promise of 10,000 homes falls due in November 2028. The term of the man who made it ends in May 2027. That, in the end, is what speculation is: selling today something that does not yet exist, with a deadline that falls after the votes have been counted. That is the real speculation, and I promise you it is not the owners doing it.
So when November 2028 comes, there will be no politician at the door giving explanations. There will be shutters down on flats nobody rented, a laundry with fewer sheets, a bar serving fewer breakfasts and a lot of people looking for another job. The 10,000 homes will not have arrived. Many of those 40,000 jobs will have gone.
Barcelona deserves someone who does the whole sum, what is gained and what is lost, and says it out loud. That is why I am writing this.
The lights fade slowly. Only the neighbour from the fifth floor is left in the theatre, the one from the beginning. This time she does not clap. She has done the maths.
Speculating on a lie
Based on a true story
- Directed by
- The election campaign
- Original screenplay
- A promise of 10,000 homes
- Special effects
- 10,000 homes that turn into 3,000
Cast, in order of appearance
- The neighbour on the fifth floor
- Herself
- The mayor
- The man with the promise
- The owner
- The one who pulled down the shutters
- The tenant
- The one left outside
- The con artist
- The one with the urgent deposit
- The short-term rental manager
- The villain who pays
- The neighbour on the second floor
- The one with the awkward question
- The hotel chain
- With cigar
- The housing minister
- With the 3%
- My father
- With the antidote
- Soundtrack
- Applause
- Budget
- More than 40,000 jobs (someone else’s)
- End of filming
- May 2027
- Release date
- November 2028
No homes were returned to the market during the making of this film.
Any resemblance to real events is entirely intentional.
THE END
Sources
- El Ayuntamiento de Barcelona prevé eliminar todos los pisos turísticos en noviembre de 2028Noticias de Navarra, 21 June 2024. The mayor’s announcement.
- Ajuntament de Barcelona: la comisión de Hacienda aprueba el recargo del IBI de los pisos turísticos9 October 2026 (in Catalan). 10,627 active licences, surcharge bands and first charge on 31 December 2027.
- Barcelona aprovecha los decretos de Sánchez y sube un 150 % el IBI a los pisos turísticosAra, 9 October 2026. Forecast of €7–8 million a year.
- INE: medición del número de viviendas turísticas en EspañaExperimental statistics. 2021 Population and Housing Census: 808,751 homes in Barcelona.
- Inside Airbnb: datos de BarcelonaOpen data (CC BY 4.0), 17 September 2026. Our own calculation: distinct licence numbers in listings, estimated revenue (€184 million) and 10% VAT on it.
- Desahuciada una vecina de 87 años en MadridAra, 23 September 2026.
- Real Decreto-ley 26/2026, de 29 de septiembrePreamble (10% VAT and property tax surcharge). Revoked by Congress on 2 October 2026 (BOE-A-2026-20526).
- Real Decreto-ley 29/2026, de 6 de octubre10% VAT from 1 December 2026 and the property tax surcharge. Ratified by Congress on 12 November 2026 (BOE-A-2026-23755).
- Derogación del Real Decreto-ley 28/2026Resolution of 12 November 2026 of the Congress of Deputies. The five-year extensions.
- En un 30 % de los pisos de la Derecha del Eixample no viven vecinosAra, 26 January 2026. Barcelona Regional data (2024 land registry and population register).
- Sentencia del Tribunal Constitucional 37/2022, de 10 de marzoStrikes down the rent-containment regime of Catalan Law 11/2020.
- Resolución de 14 de marzo de 2024, de la Secretaría de Estado de Vivienda y Agenda UrbanaStressed residential market areas in Catalonia.
- La caída de la oferta de alquiler permanente sigue destacando en las zonas tensionadasIdealista. Barcelona: long-term supply down 15% since March 2024; mid-term rentals now account for 64% of listings (34% in March 2024).
- La Guardia Civil desarticula en Madrid y Barcelona dos grupos que estafaban con falsos alquileresInfobae, 13 November 2026. Operation @RENT 5: fake adverts and payments in advance.
- Cómo detectar fraudes en el alquiler de una viviendaIdealista, 16 November 2026. The pressure to book quickly “on the grounds that lots of people are interested”.
- Informe de PwC para AparturEl Debate, 15 January 2025. More than 40,000 jobs, 1.9% of Barcelona’s GDP and €58 million in tourist tax in 2023.
- Apartur: 160 millones de euros en impuestos directosEl Cronista.
- Impuesto sobre las estancias en establecimientos turísticos (2012)And Catalan Law 2/2026, with the rates from 1 April 2026.
- Ley 13/2002, de 21 de junio, de turismo de CataluñaConsolidated text. Very serious offences and penalties.
- Barcelona ha ordenado cerrar un millar de pisos turísticos este añoAra, 2024. 10,625 closure orders since 2016.
- Barcelona pide a Airbnb la retirada de un millar de pisos turísticos ilegalesThe Objective, 8 December 2020. 11,714 listings flagged for removal since 2017.
- NYC’s rules one year laterAirbnb, with CoStar data: hotel prices in New York.
- StreetEasy: informe del mercado de Nueva York, mayo de 2026The city’s median rent.
- Constitución EspañolaArticles 33, 43 and 47.
- La vivienda social en España frente a la media europeaEl Cronista. The 3.4% figure given by the housing minister.